After much searching, I finally decided on Rolo Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies. I found a great recipe over at Sally's Baking Addiction. I had no problem following it to make these yummy treats!
The only recommendation I would have for myself if I was making them again is to make less cookies and put more dough on the top portion of the cookie. I think this would eliminate the bump on the top of them to some degree. It was the only part of the cookie that I would change from my batch.
At the cookie swap, I actually won second place. Yay! I was so excited because I have never won a prize there before. I guess it is safe to say that the cookies were a big hit with everyone!
Did you make any new treats over the holidays?
Andrea :)
Your cookies look delicious! My book club does a cookie exchange every year. This year I made Grinch cookies (peppermint flavored cake batter cookies) which came out not that great. So I also brought Congo bars, which are basically like a chocolate chip cookie in bar form, but with tons of brown sugar. They were so great! We don't award prizes though.
ReplyDeleteI also made chocolate covered cherry cookies, Nutter Butter truffles, and sugar cookies for Santa this year. It's been a busy baking season!
I attempted peppermint bark this year, it didn't turn out quit the way I had hoped! I thought about making those Rolo cookies! :) I also made Oatmeal White Chocolate Cranberry cookies, they were amazing!
ReplyDelete